EVALUATING HOSPITAL AND HEALTHCARE SERVICE QUALITY USING AN INTUITIONISTIC FUZZY MCDM FRAMEWORK: EVIDENCE FROM DISTRICT HOSPITALS IN PUNJAB
Keywords:
healthcare service quality; district hospitals; Punjab; intuitionistic fuzzy sets; MCDM; IF-AHP; IF-TOPSISAbstract
Healthcare service quality is multidimensional and difficult to evaluate because patients and healthcare managers assess different aspects of care using information that is frequently incomplete, subjective, and uncertain. This challenge is particularly relevant in Punjab, Pakistan, where empirical studies have identified gaps in responsiveness, reliability, communication, physical facilities, pharmacy and laboratory services, and waiting time. The present article develops an intuitionistic fuzzy multi-criteria decision-making (IF-MCDM) framework for evaluating district hospital service quality in Punjab. The proposed framework integrates established healthcare-quality dimensions with intuitionistic fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process (IF-AHP) for determining criterion importance and intuitionistic fuzzy Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (IF-TOPSIS) for comparing hospital alternatives. The framework is informed by published evidence from Pakistan and international applications of fuzzy and MCDM approaches to healthcare evaluation. Unlike conventional single-index or SERVQUAL-based assessments, the proposed approach can simultaneously represent membership, non-membership, and hesitation, thereby providing a more flexible representation of uncertain judgments. Published Pakistani evidence demonstrates substantial variation across service dimensions, while international studies show that fuzzy MCDM methods can support multidimensional hospital evaluation and managerial prioritization. Because no original district-hospital dataset was supplied for this manuscript, hospital-specific weights, rankings, scores, and statistical significance values are not presented as completed empirical findings. Instead, the article specifies the analytical structure and expected outputs of a future empirical application. The framework provides a systematic basis for identifying high-priority quality dimensions, comparing district hospitals, and supporting evidence-informed resource allocation and continuous quality improvement in Punjab.







