RESISTING HEGEMONY: CHINA AND RUSSIA’S COUNTER-MULTILATERAL STRATEGIES IN THE ASIA-PACIFIC AMID THE TRUMP ‘BOARD OF PEACE’ INITIATIVE, 2025-2026”
Keywords:
Board of Peace, United Nations, Great-power rivalry, Institutional legitimacy, Global governance fragmentation.Abstract
This article will analyze the rapid institutionalization of Donald Trump’s “Board of Peace” (hereafter, Peace Board) as a still emergent but institutionalizing policy body for the management of the Gaza Peace “business” (initially associated with post-ceasefire governance and reconstruction of the Gaza Strip) and, the author seeks to answer the question of whether it serves as a parallel, competitive, or, eventually, co-opted extension of the existing UN-centered peace architecture. Using realism, institutionalism, and constructivism, the analysis attempts to capture the strategic reservations of China and Russia as the UN Security Council's permanently concerned West. It posits that their reservations are less aimed at peace as an end, and more at (i) peace as a process (who decides, mandates, and orders execution), (ii) process legitimacy (law-based multilateralism v. a club of leaders governance), and (iii) legitimacy of outcomes (a club of payers and a selective geoeconomic arrangement that cuts off smaller states from the line of equity). The author posits that the Peace Board cannot simply “replace” the UN, but rather it will lead to UN (121) fragmentation by accelerating a two-tiered peace system – one with formal UN legitimacy, the other with direct, high-leverage, transactional governance peace – and the negative outcomes of such for the South and the future of collective security will be massive.







